In a new interview with Guitar World, guitarist John 5 discussed why he was the ideal choice to replace Mick Mars in MÖTLEY CRÜE. The accomplished musician shared how his decades-long familiarity with the band’s catalog made the transition effortless and deeply meaningful.
A Lifelong Connection to MÖTLEY CRÜE’s Music
When asked what made him the perfect fit among many potential guitarists, John 5 pointed to his enduring respect for MÖTLEY CRÜE’s songs and the role they’ve played in his life.
Transcribed by Guitar World:
“I think I have such respect and fondness for the music,” he said. “I’ve been playing these songs – and this is going to sound funny – but I’ve been playing these songs for as long as they have. I was in my bedroom or at a talent show, and those guys were on a huge stage, but I’ve been playing these songs since they came out.”
His response highlights a genuine passion that goes beyond professional admiration. Long before joining MÖTLEY CRÜE, John 5 had already been performing their songs privately, treating them as part of his own musical DNA.
Prepared Long Before the Call Came
Because of this lifelong practice, stepping into Mick Mars’s role came naturally. John 5 recalled that when bassist Nikki Sixx handed him the band’s setlist, he already knew the material inside out.
Transcribed by Guitar World:
“So, when Nikki [Sixx] said, ‘Okay, here’s the setlist to learn,’ I was like, ‘I know all these songs,’” he continued. “Like, of course, we all know the songs, but I could have done the show that night. And that’s just because I have such a fondness and respect for the music, and for those guys.”
That level of preparation made his integration seamless. For John 5, this wasn’t about learning something new — it was about honoring music he’d cherished for decades.
Respecting the Legacy
Replacing a founding member like Mick Mars could easily be daunting, but John 5 approached it with deep respect. He emphasized that his goal was never to reinvent MÖTLEY CRÜE’s sound, but to uphold the integrity of the classics that define the band’s legacy.
Fans have noted that John 5’s technical mastery blends perfectly with the group’s hard-hitting energy. His ability to replicate Mick Mars’s tone while adding subtle touches of his own has helped preserve the familiar sound fans love.
This respect for the band’s identity has also strengthened the bond between John 5 and longtime members Nikki Sixx, Tommy Lee, and Vince Neil.
Familiar Faces, Natural Chemistry
During the interview, John 5 shared how his pre-existing relationships with several band members eased the transition. He already knew Nikki Sixx and Tommy Lee, but met vocalist Vince Neil for the first time at Tommy Lee’s birthday party after officially joining the group.
The camaraderie was instant. According to John 5, the chemistry between the members extended beyond the stage — something essential for a band that thrives on energy and connection.
From Fan to Bandmate
For many guitarists, playing with MÖTLEY CRÜE would be a dream come true. For John 5, it’s a full-circle moment. He grew up idolizing the band, learning their songs note for note, and now finds himself sharing the stage with them.
His story resonates with musicians and fans alike — proof that genuine passion and dedication can eventually open doors to unimaginable opportunities.
Beyond the technical aspects of performance, John 5’s enthusiasm brings a renewed spark to MÖTLEY CRÜE’s live shows. Audiences have praised the energy and precision he brings to the band’s legendary hits, from “Kickstart My Heart” to “Girls, Girls, Girls.”
A Smooth Transition for MÖTLEY CRÜE
When Mick Mars officially retired from touring due to health concerns, fans worried about how MÖTLEY CRÜE would move forward. The introduction of John 5 in late 2022 reassured many that the band’s legacy would remain intact.
His arrival coincided with MÖTLEY CRÜE’s ongoing world tours, where he quickly proved himself capable of honoring the band’s history while adding his own flair. Reviews from recent performances have praised his accuracy, charisma, and chemistry with the rest of the lineup.
Maintaining the Spirit of Classic Songs
John 5 made it clear that his approach is rooted in preservation, not reinvention. His goal is to maintain the essence of the songs fans have loved for decades while delivering them with fresh enthusiasm.
His respect for MÖTLEY CRÜE’s catalog mirrors his admiration for its creators. He often refers to the band as pioneers who shaped the sound of 1980s hard rock — and he’s determined to keep that spirit alive on stage.
Looking Ahead
As MÖTLEY CRÜE continues touring and working on potential new music, John 5’s presence injects both stability and excitement into the lineup. His deep understanding of the band’s material ensures continuity, while his virtuosic guitar work adds modern power to their performances.
Fans who’ve attended recent shows have noticed how naturally John 5 fits in — as if he’s been there all along. His combination of technical brilliance, humility, and lifelong fandom has made him more than just a replacement; he’s become an essential part of the next chapter in MÖTLEY CRÜE’s story.
